15 The Stay Guide: Anguilla
Anguilla’s hotels span everything from cliffside hideaways to wide-beach resorts, and the client fit changes dramatically from one property to the next. Travel Advisors Emily Deutschman of Puffin Nest Travel Co. and Caitlin Fogle of ProTravel share firsthand insights from recent stays and site inspections across seven distinct hotels. They highlight the key trade-offs in layout, beach access, room design, service style, and onsite amenities. Their comparisons reveal clear patterns in client profiles, from families who need space and swimmable water to couples seeking privacy and a strong sense of place. Tune in for practical clarity on when to choose each hotel and how to confidently match clients to Anguilla’s very different coastal experiences.
Key Takeaways
Get familiar with hotel options in Meads Bay, considering walkability, beach clubs, and easy dining access
Which hotels in Anguilla best fit travelers who want a remote setting and expansive beach
Why Aurora Anguilla is a recommended option for families needing a full-scale resort
Which hotel in Anguilla that serves both families and clients seeking adult-only spaces
About the guest:
Emily Deutschman is the founder of Puffin Nest Travel Co., a Minneapolis-based travel consultancy specializing in culturally immersive, family-focused itineraries. After living overseas for five years and traveling extensively, she launched Puffin Nest Travel Co. in 2024 to help families explore the world with confidence and curiosity.
Caitlin Fogle began her career in social work, holding a Master’s degree and spending over a decade as a transplant social worker before pivoting into travel for greater flexibility. She first trained under her own Travel Advisor, eventually joining a host agency, and has now been in the industry for nearly three years crafting personalized trips for her clients.
